Skip to content

The 4th of June Nest of Pigs Ouster

Saturday, 8th June 2013

The following article is an attempt to fulfill this blog’s purpose at providing news analysis. However, news must be transmitted in a timely and expedient fashion, something that is beyond this writer’s capacity at the moment. Therefore, this is being published before interest on the issue wanes.

Toe the Mainstream Media Party Line

If you follow the mainstream media (MSM), you will already be familiar with scandal that occurred this week, when the Philippine Daily Inquirer published the following controversial comic strip (PDI filename “pug130406.jpg”) by veteran cartoonist Apolonio “Pol” Medina, Jr.

Alt Text

Controversial “Pugad Baboy” comic strip “pug130406”, published by the Philippine Daily Inquirer, 4 June 2013.

At first glance, the matter seems cut and dried:

  1. On Tuesday, 4 June 2013, Mr. Medina authors a tasteless comic storyline in which “Bop”, a generic gay character accuses Christians of being hypocrites in their dealing with homosexuals.
  2. The punch line actually names St. Scholastica’s College as a haven for lesbian activity and accuses the staff, the Missionary Benedictine Sisters of Tutzing of deliberately encouraging such activities.
  3. In essence, impugning the reputation of a century-plus-old academic institution as well as slander against the parents, currently enrolled students, and about eight generations of very wealthy and politically powerful alumni.
  4. Naturally, there is considerable anger as the extended St. Scholastica family spreads the news of this “singular” insult throughout the social media.
  5. In response, the Board of Trustees of St. Scholastica’s College threatens legal action against the Philippine Daily Inquirer “unless an inquiry is launched”.
  6. On Wednesday, 5 June 2013, the Philippine Daily Inquirer suspends Mr. Medina who then chooses to fall on his sword when he realizes the shame and loss of political capital he has his patron, Mrs. Letty Magsanoc.
  7. On Friday, 7 June 2013, the Philippine Daily Inquirer tearfully, but reluctantly accepts Mr. Medina’s letter of resignation .

Having arrived at the “facts” presented, the reading public is now encouraged by the MSM to express outrage against in order to perhaps defend freedom of speech, or freedom of the press or simply “show support” of the artwork of Mr. Medina which has garnered a quarter century of fans across the Philippines, now portrayed as yet another plucky journalist who has been silenced by powerful interests.

Already, a number of communities on the Internet are using the controversy to further their own political agendas.

However, upon closer inspection, a number of details seem to have been lost in the MSM whitewash, causing the Filipino libertarian community to express reasonable doubt on the entire chain of events presented.

Questions We are Not Supposed to Ask:

  • Why was Mr. Medina the only person to be suspended by the Philippine Daily Inquirer?
  • Mr. Medina is no stranger to editorial censorship and has had his work refused by the PDI before, (See Medina, A. Ink & Politics 1.) so why is there no mention of any disciplinary action against the editor of the Entertainment section who had the editorial authority to allow or disallow the printing of “pug130406.jpg”?
  • Was Tuesday, 4 June 2013, the first time “pug130406.jpg” was published in the PDI?
  • What was the Pugad Baboy story arc that began on Monday, 3 June 2013 and how did “pug130406.jpg” fit into it?
  • Finally, who benefits from the controversy?

Analysis of PDI Internal File Numbering

On Monday, 3 June 2013, the Philippine Daily Inquirer published the first of the week’s series of Pugad Baboy comic strips featuring commentary by Adagulfo “Mang Dagul” Sungcal Jr. on the seeming resurgence of Kilusang Bagong Lipunan loyalists on the Internet. It is marked in the PDI Archive as “pug130603.jpg”.

The Philippine Daily Inquirer serializes filenames in it’s directory using a simple “pugYYMMDD” format, where “pug” represents “Pugad Baboy” accompanied by a six figure numbered date. YY = year, MM = month, and DD = day. This is to represent the date of publication. The other two remaining comics strips sharing the same storyline are, as expected, also internally serialized in the same manner.

Medina, A. (3 June 2013). Pugad Baboy. Intended date: 3 June 2013.

Medina, A. (3 June 2013). Pugad Baboy “pug130603.jpg”. Intended date: 3 June 2013.

However, the comic strip identified as “pug130604.png” and originally intended for Tuesday, 4 June 2013 is mysteriously delayed until Thursday, 6 June 2013 and replaced by the now-infamous “pug130406.jpg”.

Medina, A. (6 June 2013). Pugad Baboy. Intended date: 4 June 2013.

Medina, A. (6 June 2013). Pugad Baboy. Intended date: 4 June 2013.

When one reads the story arc in its intended order, (“pug130603.jpg” followed by “pug130604.png”), you can get a sense of continuity of the narrative.

In “pug130603.jpg”, Mang Dugal is at his laptop, commenting on a number of pro-KBL posts on Facebook. Next to him is Polgas on a second laptop. The scene in “pug130604.png” remains the same. Two characters sitting side-by-side with laptops, talking about pro-KBL posts on Facebook. Even the clothing of the characters is the same, which gives one the idea that these two comic strips were drawn one after the other in rapid succession. In “pug130603.jpg”, Mang Dugal mentions posts, which could anywhere on the Internet, however, in in “pug130604.png”, Facebook is mentioned telling the reader that the previously mentioned posts were actually Facebook status updates. Again, a sense of continuity in the narrative.

Thus, “pug130605.jpg” also gives a sense of time, with Mang Dagul and Polgas conversing later in the day, but continuing the same narrative.

Medina, A. (5 June 2013). Pugad Baboy. Intended date: 5 June 2013.

Medina, A. (5 June 2013). Pugad Baboy. Intended date: 5 June 2013.

If we were to follow the PDI’s actual publication order, Mang Dagul begins a rant about pro-KBL in  “pug130603.jpg” then the anti-Marcos story-arc suddenly shifts perspective to “pug130406.jpg”, after which the anti-Marcos arc returns with Mang Dagul in the kitchen, and finishes up with “pug130604.png” showing Mang Dagul having changed back into the same shirt as in “pug130603.jpg”.

The following chart shows this story arc discrepancy quite clearly.

PDI Filename

Intended Publication Order

Actual Date of Publication

pug130603.jpg Monday, 3 June 2013 Monday, 3 June 2013
pug130406.jpg Saturday, 6 April 2013 Tuesday, 4 June 2013
pug130605.jpg Wednesday, 5 June 2013 Wednesday, 5 June 2013
pug130604.png Tuesday, 4 June 2013 Thursday, 6 June 2013
(missing) Friday, 7 June 2013
(missing) Saturday, 8 June 2013

A glance at the Philippine Daily Inquirer’s Pugad Baboy Archive confirms the anomalous placement of “pug130406.jpg” in the publication order.

Pugad Baboy Archive, Page 1

Pugad Baboy Archive, Page 1

What can be concluded from the evidence is that publication of “pug130406.jpg” required editorial authority, which Mr. Medina, as a contributor did not. A quick glance at the Management Team page of the PDI shows a certain Emy Velarde as the Editor for the Entertainment section.

As of this writing, there has been no mention of any censure or disciplinary action against her.

Origins of “pug130406.jpg”

On Thursday, 6 June 2013 at 9:32 am, Mr. Medina posted his version of events on his Facebook page:

Medina, A. (6 June 2013). Facebook post.

Medina, A. (6 June 2013). Facebook post.

“if you zoom in on that particular strip that got me fired, you’ll see that the strip first appeared in MARCH. no reaction then. it was reissued after i made a series of anti-marcos strips, then BOOM! nag-trending sa twitter. interesting. i smell a consPIGracy….”

https://www.facebook.com/polmedinajr/posts/388451944605662

A close-up on panel 2 of “pug130406.jpg” shows Mr. Medina’s own production code, “PMJR-MM-YY”, where “PMJR” are his initials accompanied by a four  figure numbered date. MM = month and YY = year. This is to represent the date the comic strip was created.

Close-up of panel 2 showing production code "PMJR0313".

Close-up of panel 2 showing production code “PMJR0313”.

This more or less gives credence to the theory that publication of “pug130406.jpg” on Tuesday, 4 June 2013 was an approved editorial decision, out of the hands of Mr. Medina.

However, a close-up on panel 1 of “pug130406.jpg” shows a second production code, marked as “PMJR0413”.

Close-up of panel 1 showing production code "PMJR0413". Taken from the PDI Archive.

Close-up of panel 1 showing production code “PMJR0413”. Taken from the PDI Archive.

N.B.: As of this writing, this comic strip has been removed from the PDI Archive and Mr. Medina has not yet shown the original.

This second production code “PMJR0413” tallies somewhat with the PDI’s archive code “pug130406”. Comic strips “pug130603.jpg”, “pug130605.jpg” and “pug130604.png” all bear the production code “PMJR0613”.

N.B.: Without further information available, we speculate that Mr. Medina’s code not only acts as a batch production date, but also as an “editorial check” granting the PDI Entertainment Editor, Emy Velarde, express permission to reprint an old comic strip.

Another look at the Philippine Daily Inquirer’s Pugad Baboy Archive shows that the comic slated for Saturday, 6 April 2013 is actually missing. Further evidence of editorial involvement.

Pugad Baboy Archive, Page 5

Pugad Baboy Archive, Page 5

There seems to be some discrepancy towards the employment status of Mr. Medina’s employment with the PDI as of Wednesday, 5 June 2013.

Diola, C. (2013, 6 June). Pugad Baboy creator claims ‘conPIGracy’ over suspended strip. Philippine Star. Retrieved from http://www.philstar.com/news-feature/2013/06/06/950848/pugad-baboy-creator-claims-conpigracy-over-suspended-strip

At this point in time, the official statement of the PDI says that Mr. Medina is “under suspension” but Mr. Medina claims to have been fired. He does retract his comments lightly later on.

“What? wait … Hindi pa pala ako fired. suspended lang hanggang magkaroon ng consensus na sipain ako. pero. Doon din siguro ang punta no’n. Sigh,”

This attitude is susprisingly in contrast to Mr. Medina’s resignation letter on Friday, 7 June 2013.

The resignation letter of Pol Medina, Jr., addressed to Philippine Daily Inquirer Editor-in-Chief Letty Jimenez Magsanoc. -- Photo courtesy of Chiara Zambrano, ABS-CBN News

The resignation letter of Pol Medina, Jr., addressed to Philippine Daily Inquirer Editor-in-Chief Letty Jimenez Magsanoc. — Photo courtesy of Chiara Zambrano, ABS-CBN News

Questions We are Not Supposed to Ask:

  • If what Mr. Medina says is accurate and that this code does in fact denote production date, (and what we speculate to be author consent), then why does “pug130406.jpg” not show a third production code “PMJR0613”?
  • Is it possible that Mr. Medina did not choose to resign over the furor caused by “pug130406.jpg”, but was asked to quietly resign (was fired) over his Facebook postings?

[To be continued]

No comments yet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

The Developer's Tidbits

Helpful tips for random problems

Stormfields

Christian Humanism in a Post-Modern World

artandliturgy.wordpress.com/

Sacred art, architecture, and the liturgy for normal people.

Rosary Collector

Learn the history of unique rosaries, center medals and crosses

Intermissions

Married Life and Leisure

Tales from the Private Sector

Private Intelligence, Cyber Security and Military History

Iglesia Ni Cristo - Silent No More by Antonio Ramirez Ebangelista

This is the Official Website of Antonio Ebangelista

Preservation in Pink

Historic preservation, coffee, community + pink flamingos

Wandering American

The life of a guy living in China and actually kind of enjoying it.

The Blog of Author Tim Ferriss

Tim Ferriss's 4-Hour Workweek and Lifestyle Design Blog

Traveler on Foot

Photo-essays and travel narratives

1catholicsalmon

Swimming upstream against the tide.

Rock in China

Underground music in China

Church Militant TV News

Truth in Catholic Reporting

HECHO AYER

Because good things were made yesterday.

Dominus mihi adjutor

The Lord is my help - a monk's-eye view of things

Listening in the Desert

I'm totally dependent on You, Father.

BICOL-MAN

"Be Cool Man"

%d bloggers like this: